Mittwoch, 2. November 2011

Why I love the N9 and things I didn't know about WP7

With last week's Nokia World and today's hands-on event in Vienna, I got a chance to try out the WP7 devices and ask questions about them. Here's some insights that I want to share with you, because they might not be obvious if you haven't tried WP7 before (I haven't until last week, and these things were not obvious to me). I'm comparing the Lumia 800 with the N9 here, because they look very similar from the outside.

As the outer shell is basically the same (or in other words: all hardware features that they fitted into the N9's form factor could just as well be fitted into the Lumia 800 form factor), these things are software limitations that are in WP7 right now (doesn't mean that these will stay in the future). Most basic things that the N9 can do (and the WP7 devices can't yet) can even be done by the N900 and Symbian devices. It's also written from a pure end user experience perspective - I've talked about SDK availability earlier.
  • The Lumia 800 has a camera hardware button - the N9 does not. I would really like the N9 to have a hardware camera button (what's the progress on getting one of the volume keys to act as shutter button?)
  • If you turn off the Lumia 800, wake-up alarms won't work - they do work on the N9, i.e. with an alarm set and the N9 turned off, the N9 will turn itself on and ring the alarm
  • If you receive a call from a number that's not on your phone book, you can't directly add it to your phone book - you have to copy the number, then go to the contacts, create a new contact and paste the number there - on the N9, there's a button for this - and it even allows you to "Add new" or "Merge"
  • The N9 has NFC - the Lumia 800 does not (WP7 does not support NFC at the moment)
  • The N9 has TV-out - the Lumia 800 does not (on the other hand, some Symbian devices have HDMI out in addition to TV-out - that would have been nice for the N9 as well ;)
  • The N9 can be used in USB Mass Storage Mode - the Lumia 800 can not
  • The N9 shows the time (+missed calls/new mails/SMS) on its low-power standby screen (like the N8 and E7) thanks to the AMOLED screen - the Lumia 800 has the same screen technology, but (due to WP7 not supporting it, as I've been told) there's no low-power standby screen (the lock screen when the device is reactivated does have more information, though)
  • You can send and receive files via Bluetooth on the N9 - I've been told that you can't do this with the Lumia 800 (Update: According to Allan, there is an app for transferring contacts from an old phone to the new one - no info about arbitrary files yet)
  • The N9's marvelous virtual keyboard (an open source project, by the way) has very good tactile feedback - on WP7, the only feedback you can get is an audible one (although a long-time WP7 user told me that the virtual keyboard there is very good, even without tactile feedback)
  • Swipe. It really makes a difference
What's the point you ask? These are the things that let the N9 really shine compared to its WP7 "successor" (I don't talk about openness, SSH-into-ability, QML, hackability, Python goodness and other things here - that's something that developers like and really, really care about) for end users (it obviously also ignores apps, services, "ecosystems", but I'd argue that the things that I personally need are available on the N9 as well).

It also shows that when a vendor controls both hardware and software, they might be able to put together a more interesting HW/SW mix compared to the situation where someone else controls the software. And it really lets me look forward to the Next Billion(tm) and QML there. But for now, let's enjoy the N9 and create some cool apps (and games) for it, like a FM Radio GUI for javispedro's fmrx app or gPodder 3 (coming soon) maybe?


revoltism hat gesagt…

Really awesome post! Thanks a lot ;)

Allan hat gesagt…

Hi, sorry but you have a point wrong ;)
"You can send and receive files via Bluetooth on the N9 - I've been told that you can't do this with the Lumia 800"
You can of course ! I've transfered my 300+ contacts from my N9 to a Lumia 800 in less than 5s, via bluetooth of course (and the very usefull Nokia Transfer App) :)

thp hat gesagt…

Allan: Thanks for the clarification. Can you also send arbitrary files (MP3s, photos, ZIP files, etc..) via Bluetooth directly from one mobile device to another, without using an intermediary PC to do the transfer?

Allan hat gesagt…

thp: I haven't tried yet but will do as soon as I can (this week-end max) and I will then comment back here. During the mean time, here one of my video showing this contacts' transfer via bluetooth: Sorry, it is in French.

Allan hat gesagt…

unfortunately, no other possible transferts via bluetooth expect for contacts via the Nokia App

Jochen hat gesagt…

When my Android phone is turned off (a Motorola Droid), the alarm doesn't work either. Not sure whether other Android devices are better.

Anonym hat gesagt…

oh by the way you can add a number from an incoming call thats not in your contacts without all that copy and paste. select the phone tile, tap the number, and at the bottom of the screen is the save icon.

Qole Pejorian hat gesagt…

...And as for "hackability", which is definitely "something that developers like and really, really care about," I am still waiting for the Open Kernel to become fully available. Until then, the N9 scores pretty low on the "hackability" scale.

Jed hat gesagt…

nice post, thanks for the write-up!

Thiago hat gesagt…

Do you considered WP7 or WP7.5 in this statement?
Tanks and great post.

thp hat gesagt…

Thiago: AFAIK WP7.5 - whatever is installed on the devices that they were demoing (Lumia 800).

Jed hat gesagt…


Any phone released now (inc 800) uses WP7.5 by default.